A Biased View of The Diamond Box

The Diamond Box - Truths

According to an RJC auditor, suppliers just require to pledge that they perform strong human rights due diligence, but do not provide any proof for this. Neither does the Code of Practices call for jewelersor other downstream companiesto have traceability or chain of guardianship of their gold or diamonds. The Code of Practices is likewise weak in other substantive areas, for instance, on native peoples' legal rights and on resettlement.


In March 2017, the RJC had 342 members that had not (yet) finished the audit procedure that accredits conformity with the Code of Practices. Furthermore, companies can sign up with at any level of their operations. For example, a small subsidiary office of a large jewelry firm could apply for RJC subscription, without consisting of the remainder of the firm's entities.


The Code of Practices does not call for firms to openly report on the concrete actions they have taken to conduct due diligencea core demand of the OECD Assistance (black diamond jewellery). Its coverage commitments are obscure and do not state due persistance or the demand for business to report on the actions they have actually required to recognize, examine, and alleviate risks in their supply chains

What Does The Diamond Box Do?

A 2nd RJC standard, the Chain-of-Custody Requirement, promotes traceability and is more extensive, but adherence to it is optional for RJC members. By very early 2018, only 48 of over 1,000 participant companies had licensed entities under the requirement, including 13 jewelry experts. The Chain-of-Custody Criterion requires business to develop documentary proof of business deals along the supply chain and to validate they are not creating unfavorable impacts in conflict-affected and risky areas.


Rather, companies are allowed to choose some "entities" under their control for accreditation, leaving various other entities of a firm uncertified. While this may enable for firms to progressively switch over to more accountable sourcing methods, the existing technique also carries the danger that an entire business appreciates the reputational benefit when most of procedures is not in conformity with the standard.


All RJC member companies have to undergo an audit to demonstrate that they are compliant with the Code of Practices, and to get accreditation. Those firms that pick to get qualification for the Chain-of-Custody Criterion need to undertake a different audit. Audits are based largely on a review of the company's written plans and documents, and brows through to a "depictive collection" of centers.

The Main Principles Of The Diamond Box

It is not an extensive assessment concerning whether the firm actually executes or follows its plans throughout its operations. As an example, big business may have operations in several countries, and depend on numerous providers, however still may receive RJC certification based on check outs to just a few facilities under its straight control without any kind of exam a knockout post of several others.


Although audits are supposed to include questions on a wide series of civils rights, auditors are not constantly certified civils rights experts. As soon as the auditors complete their record, they only submit a recap report of the audit to the RJC, not the complete audit report, which is shared just with the company




While labor abuses are prevalent in the sector, artisanal mines give income for countless employees and thousands of mining neighborhoods. Human being Legal right Watch thinks that the precious jewelry industry must make every effort to guarantee that their efforts to minimize supply chain civils rights dangers do not lead them to merely exclude all artisanal providers from their supply chains as the "course of the very least resistance." Rather, they should support initiatives to define and professionalize artisanal mines and boost working conditions.


The OECD Fee Diligence Support identifies this and is promoting cost-sharing within the industry. In this way, all business along the supply chain share the economic worry. A number of initiatives have emerged that can assist jewelers map their gold and rubies to mines of origin, and a lot more properly resource from the artisanal field.

The Single Strategy To Use For The Diamond Box

Regarding 600 grown-up miners have actually been signed up at 6 mine websites; children can not register. Certification of certain mines versus liable sourcing criteria can provide jewelers with greater assurance that the gold or diamonds they buy from those mines are not tainted by human civil liberties misuses. Nongovernmental companies such as Solidaridad and influence can play a vital duty in sustaining mines to improve practices so they are able to abide by the standard; this might consist of steps to tackle kid labor, boost ecological conduct, accessibility financing, and develop straight call with customers.


(https://www.easel.ly/browserEasel/14541607)

Two standardscertify artisanal and small golden goose that adhere to human legal rights, labor civil liberties, and environmental standardsthe Fairmined Standard and the Fairtrade Gold Requirement. Both need third-party audits of private mines. The Fairmined Criterion was presented by the Partnership for Liable Mining (ARM) in 2014. Depending on the customer's license with Fairmined, the gold may be completely traceable to the mine of origin, or may be blended with various other gold.




This amount is just a tiny portion of the gold made use of yearly by numerous of the business analyzed in this report. Since very early 2018, 8 mines in four countries (Bolivia, Colombia, Mongolia, and Peru) were certified, with an added 20 mining companies working towards qualification. The Fairmined Gold Criterion is presently establishing a new "market entry" standard that looks for to help artisanal cash cow while doing so towards full certification.

Some Of The Diamond Box

It is administered under the umbrella of Fairtrade International, and allows jewelry experts to map their gold back completely to the mine of origin. Fairtrade's first qualified mines remained in Peru. Over the last few years, the Fairtrade Foundation, Solidaridad, and various other NGOs carried out a program of training and support to artisanal and small-scale gold miners in Africa, and in very early 2017, accredited an artisanal gold mine in Uganda.